Toners, Essences, Ampoules—What’s the Difference, and Do You Need Them All?

Wondering if toners, essences, or ampoules are essential for your skincare routine? Discover their key differences, benefits for, and how to choose the right products for your skin type.

If you’ve ever found yourself standing in the skincare aisle, staring at an endless row of bottles labeled toner, essence, and ampoule, wondering if you need all three (or any at all), you’re not alone.

As someone who’s worked in marketing for over a decade, I’m highly skeptical of old products, dressed up with fancy new gimmicky names, and the skincare industry is notorious for doing just that to make us buy more products.

So in the spirit of simplifying skincare, let’s talk about what, in my opinion, might be the most confusing category of all: Toners, essences, and ampoules. If you’re anything like me, you’ve poured more than one watery liquid on to your palm and wondered how it’s any different from the other watery liquid that’s meant to follow it. And more importantly, maybe you’ve asked yourself if you actually need them at all. Well, fellow skeptics, I’m going to try and answer that question today.

What Are These Products, Really?

There was a time when I couldn't tell the difference between these products, but I needed to have them anyway. Then, when better sense prevailed, I started doing some research on how they differ, and how some can cost as little as a sandwich, and others require me to sell a kidney to buy. Here’s what I found.

Toners

It’s hard to even define toners because they’ve evolved so much from their original purpose. The harsh, alcohol-filled toners of the 90s were meant to sweep up any grime or oil our cleansers had missed. But, most modern formulations are tailored for different skin concerns:

• Hydrating toners (often with ingredients like glycerin or hyaluronic acid) add moisture back into the skin.

• Exfoliating toners (with AHAs, BHAs, or PHAs) help with gentle chemical exfoliation.

• Calming toners (with ingredients like centella asiatica or green tea) soothe irritation and redness.Balancing your skin's pH after cleansing

I went through a phase where I was convinced toners were essential. I tried dozens, with lightweight, hydrating Korean toners being my absolute favourite. But then I found out that some of the products I thought were toners, were actually essences, and some were even ridiculously labeled essence toners! So, that begs the question: what’s an essence?

Essences

Essences are definitely a Korean import. They skyrocketed in popularity when Korean skincare routines took the world by storm. They're supposed to be more concentrated than toners, designed to hydrate and prep the skin for better absorption of serums and moisturizers. Essences typically contain ingredients that:

• Provide deep hydration (like hyaluronic acid or fermented extracts).

• Soothe and repair the skin barrier (like snail mucin or centella asiatica).

• Deliver ingredients with specific benefits (like ceramides and peptides).

I’ll admit, I fell for the essence hype hard after using an expensive sample of SK-II (a gift from a friend who works in beauty). But this product is also what led me to question everything I thought I knew about skincare. Because in terms of ingredients and benefits, essences didn’t look very different from toners. In fact the only time I see myself reaching for an essence is when the consistency is markedly different from that of a toner, like in the case of the Mixsoon Bean Essence or CosRx Snail Mucin Essence.

Ampoules

And then there are ampoules, the most recent K-beauty marketing gimmick category of products to cause a stir in the online world. Believers will tell you that ampoules are supercharged serums packed with a high concentration of active ingredients. Ampoules are often used as short-term treatments for specific concerns, such as:

• Brightening (with vitamin C or niacinamide)

• Hydration (with hyaluronic acid or ceramides)

• Anti-aging (with retinol or peptides)

• Barrier repair (with centella or ceramides)

Of all the categories, ampoules seem to be the one which people are playing the most fast and loose with. Some of them are as lightweight as toners and essences, some of them are closer to serums. Some are meant to be used once a day or as needed, some are daily treatments. Some are packaged in small serum-like bottles, while others are sold as single-dose capsules to break and apply. So how to tell if you even need this, or any of these products at all?

So, Do You Need All Three?

The short answer? No.

The long answer? After all the money spent and time wasted, here's what I've concluded: most of us don't need separate toners, essences, AND ampoules. In fact, many of us might not need any of them at all. It all depends on your skin’s needs and how much you enjoy layering products.

You Might Need a Toner if:

• You have oily, acne-prone skin that needs additional exfoliation

• You’ve got dry or dehydrated skin which none of the other products in your routine are adequately hydrating

Consider an essence if:

• Your skin is chronically damaged and dehydrated despite using other calming, hydrating products

• You live in an extremely dry climate

• You've tried one and seen noticeable, consistent results

Ampoules can be useful:

• For specific, temporary skin issues (e.g. seasonal changes)

• Before special events when you want an extra boost

How I Decided What Was Right for Me

After years of overcomplicating my routine, here's what actually improved my skin:

1. Identifying what my skin really needs I started looking at the toner/essence/ampoule step as optional, and only considered products that would augment my existing routine. I already had active ingredients like Vitamin C and Retinoids to target my specific concerns, but I knew I could use some added hydration and barrier support.

2. Prioritizing formulas over form At the end of the day, whether something’s an essence, a toner, or an ampoule makes no difference to me. I’m looking for ingredients that will deliver the benefits I’m looking for, and the form those ingredients come in is irrelevant.

3. Simplifying my routine When my skin was at its worst, adding more products didn't help. Stripping back to basics and focusing on barrier repair did. To keep my routine simple, I try and stick to just one of these watery products, but might add an additional one if it has a particularly beneficial ingredient that’s hard to find in other formulations (the Mixsoon Bean Essence is one such example)

4. Being able to recognize when I’m doing too much I've learned to notice the telltale signs of when I'm overcomplicating things. Each time I've noticed these issues, the solution has always been to do less, not more:

• Products pilling or rolling into little balls off when you apply them

• Skin feeling sensitive or irritated

• Breaking out in places I normally don't

• Products feeling heavy or not quite absorbing fully

• Not being able to tell what each product is actually doing in my routine

The Reality of Skincare

Here's what I wish someone had told me years ago: Skincare should be simple. It should address your actual needs, not imagined flaws. And most importantly, it shouldn't require a 10-step routine to actually work. Remember, skincare is personal. What works for me might not work for you, and that's okay. The most important thing is to pay attention to what your skin is telling you, not what marketing wants you to believe.

If your multi-step routine genuinely makes your skin better and the process brings you joy, that's great. But if you've been adding products because you think you "should," or because your favorite influencer uses them, it might be time to reconsider. Here’s a little challenge I set for myself when I first started my journey to skinimalism. If you're currently using all three steps—toner, essence, and ampoule—try this: eliminate two of them for two weeks and see if your skin actually changes. Take photos before and after. Be brutally honest with yourself about the results.

I'd be interested to hear about your experiences. Have you found any of these products to be game-changers, or have you also simplified your routine over time?

About The Skinimalist

Hi, I’m Mal, a 30-something recovering skincare addict, and this is my blog. A space where I attempt to de-influence you from chasing trends and buying more skincare products you may not need.

Related Posts: